Why is wetland restoration needed?
No matter who you are, or where you live, wetlands affect your life. In present day Wisconsin there is growing recognition of the significant and economically valuable contributions wetlands make to clean water, flood prevention, recreation, scenic beauty and wildlife habitat. However, for most of Wisconsin’s history, our predecessors looked at wetlands as areas of little importance, as "wastelands' that became valuable after they were drained or filled. Until the early 1970s, federal policy promoted draining wetlands, and many federal and state programs expended large sums to bring vast areas of wetland under cultivation. Ditching drained the water from these soggy areas, while rivers and streams were deepened and straightened to speed drainage after a rainfall. Later, farmers used extensive drain tile systems under wetlands to remove water more efficiently from cropland; loggers cleared forested swamps of trees for timber; and developers filled wetlands to create land for houses, roads, or commercial buildings. As a result, half of the original 10 million acres of wetlands in Wisconsin have been lost.
Over the past three decades the vital role wetlands play in maintaining the overall health of our environment has become clearer. Yet, even as we begin to recognize the complexity and importance of wetlands and establish state and national measures to protect them, small wetlands statewide continue to be filled for development or drained for agricultural activities. Indirect impacts due to urban runoff, rural development, and invasion by exotic species further degrade wetlands. The cumulative statewide loss is considerable, not only in quantity, but also in wetland quality. Many of our remaining original wetlands, about five million acres, are seriously degraded by a variety of threats. Read about a WWA effort to assess threats to 12 different wetland community types around the state through our Wetland Threats Analysis.
Wetland Restoration, Enhancement & Creation
Various terms are used in reference to wetland restoration. Definitions follow
for several key terms that are used to describe different types of wetland projects.
Wetland restoration is defined as the reestablishment of wetland
conditions similar to the original condition in an area where wetlands were
altered by past human activities.
Many of the state’s former wetlands are significantly disturbed and
have been altered by such activities as ditching, drain tile installation,
stream channelization, and sedimentation. These areas generally have
hydric soils typical of wetlands, and may have some wetland plants growing
among weeds or crops. The key to wetland restoration of these sites is
reestablishing the area’s original hydrology and topography, and restoring
natural processes including the original native plant cover.
Wetland enhancement is defined as the maintenance and management of existing wetlands
for a particular function or value, sometimes at the expense of other functions or values. Degrees of enhancement activity range from simple measures to more complex activities. Generally, wetland enhancement activities are used to restore severely degraded wetlands to higher quality sites. Enhancement includes management activities that affect wildlife habitat and vegetation. These activities compensate for natural processes that no longer exist. Examples include using prescribed burns, controlling invasive species, planting upland buffer zones, and providing nest boxes for wildlife.Wetland enhancement can change the physical characteristics of a functioning wetland. Examples include impounding water behind a dike
or dam at higher levels than historically present or dredging a pond in a relatively undisturbed wetland. These activities usually require permits and result in enhancing one wetland function at the expense of others. Enhancement techniques should be evaluated carefully, because one generation’s enhancement could create unintended problems for the next generation.
Wetland creation is the establishment of a wetland in an area where
a wetland never existed historically. We create artificial wetlands by impounding water behind a dike or dam or excavating surface soils in
upland areas to create a depression. These efforts are costly and laborintensive
and the resulting "wetland" may not fit into the landscape and
may never function as a natural wetland. Wetland creation requires a
higher level of science than presently available.
The first problem encountered in creating wetlands is establishing
suitable wetland hydrology. Even if that is accomplished, hydric soils
appear to be critical to establishing a healthy wetland plant community. It
is difficult to create the soil conditions that were formed by natural
processes over thousands of years.
What kind of restoration has the best track record?
Based on the hundreds of wetland restorations and wetland enhancements
and alterations that have been made across the state during the last 50
years, we are beginning to learn what works and what doesn’t. The most
ecologically sound and most cost-efficient approach to wetland restoration
is to restore degraded, formerly drained wetlands by systematically
undoing the activities that were done to alter them.
Wetland Restoration Project Goals
There are a variety of restoration techniques and approaches that can be employed depending upon the restoration goals for a particular site. Restoration goals range from comprehensive to simple improvements:
1. Historic Restoration- Returning the site to a close approximation of original topography and
wetland hydrology are goals of historic restoration. You use the information
you gathered to reverse each site impact. In the end, you want to create
a self-sustaining site and let natural processes restore the wetland. A
variety of techniques, specific to each site, are often used to reach this
goal.
2. Restoration Within Limits- Not all sites can be restored to their historic state. Often, you may
own only a part of the original wetland and some ditches must be
retained to avoid flooding neighboring lots. If your neighbors will
not join in with you, it may still be worthwhile to create the best
restoration you can within the confines of your circumstances. The
goal of the project is then to create a self-sustaining system within
limitations by using as many tools as you can.
3. Small Shallow Marsh Scrapes- Creating a series of shallow water bodies that attract wetland
wildlife, including waterfowl, in lands formerly converted to cropland
from wetland is a goal of shallow scrape projects. Many of these
sites are constructed as small potholes in cropped fields, often using
drain tile breaks, scrapes, and berms to trap water. Usually successful
at attracting waterfowl, these projects do require berm maintenance
and may not be self-sustaining wetlands in the long term. This
approach is not recommended for functional native wetlands.
4. Management/Enhancement of Wetland- These projects aim to increase the overall plant and animal diversity on your site via active management. Many sites are severely
degraded by invasive plants. An example of a management/
enhancement plan would be to initiate a prescribed burn, eliminate
the invasive plant species, and plant a buffer zone of native prairie
grasses to encourage wildlife habitat and nesting areas.
Restoration Handbook for Wisconsin Landowners
Protecting and restoring Wisconsin's wetland heritage will require involvement of many partner agencies and organizations. And because the majority of Wisconsin’s wetlands are located on privately owned land, individual landowners play a crucial role in protecting and restoring wetlands. These webpages are provided as a starting place for landowners and others interested in restoring wetlands on their lands and in their communities.
Content for our restoration webpages is excerpted from WWA's Wetland Restoration Handbook for Wisconsin Landowners, 2nd Edition (2004) by Alice L. Thompson and Charles S. Luthin. Both editions of the Handbook have
won the Wisconsin Library Association's Distinguished Document
Award. To learn more about this publication and order a copy, see WWA's publications list. To download PDF versions of Handbook chapters, visit Wisconsin DNR's website.
WWA thanks Wisconsin Coastal Management Program for providing funding support for our wetland restoration outreach efforts, including development of these webpages.
Back to Top